IR
-
Characteristics of a state: territory,
legitimate government, loyal population,
recognition of other states
-
Values of state systems: security
(realism), freedom (liberalism), order
and justice (int. society), welfare
(IPE)
-
Values of international society:
international peace and security, state
sovereignty, self-determination,
non-intervention, non-discrimination
Westphalian Society
-
Peace of Westphalia in 1648. Set the
principles of sovereignty.
-
Based on secular principles: every king
is independent, ruler decides on values
and norms, states would mutually assure
balance of power
-
Non-intervention: states would not
intervene with values of other states
-
Principles: equality, legitimacy,
diplomacy, balance of power
-
In 1960 this system became international
la
Realism
-
states are principal actors, of central
importance
-
states are unitary and rational
-
national security issues are most
important
-
international system is an anarchy, no
authority above states
-
pessimistic view of human nature
Classical Realism - focuses on
human nature, as unchanging and
self-interested. Allows to some extent
certain values and norms, universally
applied. Most important concept in
international politics is power.
Political sphere is autonomous,
independent on other spheres.
Classical Realists: Thucydides,
Machiavelli, Hobbes (Security Dilemma),
Neorealism - structure - anarchy.
Anarchy determines behavior. Outcome of
anarchy is balance of power. Maintenance
of balance of power is key to int. peace
and security. Ultimately states will act
to help themselves.
Neorealists: Morgenthau, Waltz,
Mearscheimer
-
multipolar: power divided by 3 or more
countries
-
bipolar: two states have almost same
power and much more than other states
Liberalism
-
non state actors more important
-
multiple issues: environmental,
population growth, trade, human rights
etc
-
human nature is not evil
-
belief in progress and peaceful and
cooperative solutions
-
states are not main actors, we do not
live in absolute anarchy
-
rights and freedoms of individual
Classical Liberalists: Locke,
Bentham, Kant.
Sociological Liberalism:
relations between individuals, groups &
societies. Transnationalism - relations
that cross borders, not just state-state
relations. Traits of modernization -
Internet, development of European
society. Globalization - emergence of
global culture, economic transformation,
global civic society.
Interdependence Liberalism:
states depend on each other.
Modernization increases level of
interdependence between states.
Transnational actors important. Welfare
not security most important issue.
Institutional Liberalism:
international institutions promote
cooperation between states. Reduce
state's fear of each other. Can emerge
naturally, voluntarily, promoting common
good.
Republican Liberalism:
Democracies won't go to war with each
other. Democracies have economic ties,
same values, idea of peaceful conflict
resolution etc
Decision-making Liberalism: how
certain aspects of domestic
decision-making influences important
outcomes.
International Society
-
middle way between realists and
liberalists. IR a society of sovereign
states
-
states are sovereign, but certain
principles do exist
-
main actors - statespeople
-
values: order, justice, state
sovereignty, human rights
-
main point - preservation and promotion
of international order. Great powers
have responsibility to sustain order
between states.
-
Three types of responsibilities:
national, international and humanitarian
International Societist: Hedley
Bull ("International Society")
IPE
-
relationship between politics and
economics
-
debates: hegemonic stability,
development & underdevelopment,
globalization & changing role of states
Mercantilism: economy should
serve politics. National interests rule
over market place. States are main
actors, state power - economic goal.
Excessive economic dependence should be
avoided. When economic and security
interests conflict, security should have
priority.
Economic Liberalism: free market
economy, minimum government
interference. Economic sphere is
autonomous. Individuals and private
firms main actors. Market economy -
autonomous sphere. Economic goal -
maximum well-being. Adam Smith.
Marxism: economy is inequality
between social classes. Wealth of rich
is dependent on poverty of poor.
Politics is determined by socio-economic
content. Looks at states and nonstate
actors in terms of classes cooperating
in a capitalist system. Historical
evolution evolves from class
differences. Issues of war and peace
deriving from economic causes. Two
elements of society: substructure and
superstructure. Two classes: bourgeoisie
and proletariat. Most important debate -
development and underdevelopment in the
III world.
WORLD SYSTEM THEORY - divides the
world into three parts - core, periphery
and semi-periphery. Raw material prices
stay the same while the costs of
products are increasing. Unequal
exchange - wages and work rights do not
match in the core and periphery.
DEPENDENCY THEORY - periphery
most dependent on production of raw
material. Existence of separatist states
despite capitalist theory of spreading
Methodology
-
the way we gather facts and knowledge
influences outcome
-
conclusions are influenced by processes
used to come to them.
Post-positive theories: critical
theory, post-modernism theory,
constructivism, and normative theory.
Critical theory: very critical of
positivism - believes that positivists
are so concentrated on status quo, too
conservative. Should take broader
viewpoint. All knowledge is biased.
Knowledge inherently political.
Post-modernism theory: Rejects
idea that objectivity is possible. Very
critical of big theories of the world.
Believe world is too biased and changing
to have such broad and general theories.
Theories contaminated by standpoints and
prejudices.
Constructivism: our understanding
of the world is a social construction.
Emphasize role of shared knowledge and
ideas of the social world. Anarchy is
what states make of it (Wendt). If our
shared knowledge of the world changes,
we can also change.
Normative theory: moral aspects
of international relations. Look at the
world as it ought to be. Relationship
between facts and values - they
shouldn't be separated. Relativism
- values are not universal, usually are
specific to particular cultures,
circumstances. Universalism -
there are certain values that apply to
all circumstances.
International law sets normative
framework
-
laws of war (states won't attack
each other unless in self defense).
Borders sacred. Legal wars
-
laws in war - what are legal and
illegal forms of conduct in war.
Can't kill non-combatants, protect
civilians, soldiers have right to
surrender, Red Cross territories
respected as neutral etc.
Individuals as well as states can be
held responsible for violating these
laws.
Other Issues:
- Gender: Anne Tickner,
reformulated Morgenthau's 6 principles
of the realist view of the world.
Feminists especially critical of
realism. Liberal feminism:
emphasizes equality between men and
women. Examined in terms of sameness.
Women need greater representation in
arenas of w. politics. Women are
underrepresented. Look at promoting more
equality, increasing female roles in
politics etc.
N
ew
identification terms:
IRREDENTISM - goal of regaining
lost property
SECESSION - efforts by a sub
state area to draw borders around itself
and create own state
ETHNOCENTRISM - see own group
favorably and out-group in unfavorable
terms, even to point where other group
is dehumanized so that it becomes
feasible to violently attack.
DÉTENTE - regulating arms race -
emergence of more cooperative relations
between the US and Russia in the 1970's.
MAD - Mutually Assured of
Destruction - During Cold War - both
countries had far more than enough to
massively retaliate
PROLIFERATION - spread of various
types of weapons capabilities to states
that had previously lacked these
capabilities.
SELF DETERMINATION - group that
feels dominated might want greater
influence in decisions.
CULTURAL RELATIVITY - idea that
there are certain cultural practices
that can't be judged by other countries
UNIVERSALISM - idea that there
are particular norms and they should be
universal to all countries.
SEPARATISM - when a group of
people wants own territory
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT -
development that meets the needs of the
present without compromising the ability
of the future generations to fulfill
their needs.
DESPARITY - differences in wealth
THE COMMONS - areas of the world
that arent individually owned (oceans
etc)
COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE -
production of a good service at a lower
cost than the competitions.
DETTERENCE - when a state
presents a credible military threat to
its potential enemy
GNP - Gross National Product -
total monetary value of all goods and
services produced by economy in given
year.
HARD CURRENCY - currencies used
in international markets -corporations
and governments accept them
IMPORT SUBSITUTION - an economic
strategy to avoid trade but work on
development - developing local
industries to replace imports
EXPORT LED GROWTH - country will
develop industries that can compete in
world market.
INDIGENOUS PEOPLE - the original
people of an area who have lost
political control over their ancestral
lands (ex. Nunavut in Canada)
IMF - International Monetary Fund
- provides loans to other members to
stabilize their currency
GLOBALIZATION - spread of a
culture to other states, emergence of
one world-dominant culture.
PATERNALISM - acting as a father,
doing for someone's "own good".
NATIONALISM - and individual's
feeling of identity within an ethnic
group based on shared traits - language,
religion, culture, history
PERCEPTUAL SELECTIVITY - some
information gets to through to conscious
thought, while other facts may be
ignored or misinterpreted.
IGO - International Governmental
Organization - where states are members
(UN, EU)
NGO - Non Governmental
Organization - where individuals or
private groups are members (Red Cross
etc)
PROTECTIONISM - a government
policy using tariffs and other
regulations to restrict imports and keep
out foreign competition.
ASSIMILATION - a view that people
will people will eventually give up
customs of inferior culture to become
members of a superior one.
RACISM - judging of groups or
individuals based on culturally defined
understandings of biological
differences.
COMMUNITARIALISM - view that a
group is more important than the
individual when thinking about rights.
TOLERANCE - acceptance of
cultural differences without
ethnocentric judgment.
Ethnicity
and Global Diversity
-
Hunters and gatherers: People in
bands share with one another. All
benefit from the successes of any one
individual. Once the plats and animals
of one area are depleted, they are
forced to move their camps to a new
place. No designated leaders in bands.
Competition between bands is minimal.
Cooperation is essential ideal.
-
Agriculturalists: own personal
possessions. Some are more prestigious
than others. Poorer clans become
dependent on the generosity of richer
ones in times of need. Equality not an
ideal. Social rank becomes issue.
Outstanding individuals are recognized
and followed.
-
Pastoralists: farmers as well,
but consider farming secondary in status
to herding cattle. Nomadic movement.
Differences in wealth are clear, dictate
difference in status. Raiding is common.
-
State organization: primitive
states are dependent on agriculture as
major source of food. Economic
specialization and market exchange.
Certain groups of people are considered
inherently better than others. Warfare
common. Industrialism changes focus from
farm to factory.
Biologically there is only once race -
homo sapiens, all closely related. The
typical division of races are social
arrangements. Typical race categories in
US: Native American, American Asian,
African, Hispanic, Caucasian. These
differences are largely social, not
created by biological differences.
Forces that give a nation a sense of
collective identity: religion, language,
history etc.
Classes: ascribed status - born into,
already have royal titles or wealth.
Achieved status - one earned by actions
of individual.
CULTURAL RELATIVITY - idea that
there are certain cultural practices
that can't be judged by other cultures.
(cultural pluralism)
UNIVERSALISM - idea that there
are particular norms that could and
should be universal to all countries.
(global unity).
Perspectives: state
primacy, global unity, cultural
pluralism
State primacy - ultimate
goal:state sovereignty. Patriotism.
Seeks to strengthen present system. Sees
states as important to world peace. Sees
current system as good.
Global Unity - goal: unified
world system. Assimilation. Seeks
political integration. Sees states as
artificial constructs. Sees current
system as overly differentiated.
Cultural Pluralism - goal:
cultural autonomy. Tolerance and
diversity. Seeks to increase power of
ethnic groups. Sees states as artificial
constructs. Sees current system as
overly centralized.
NATIONALISM
-
positive vs. negative
Positive: provides sense of belonging.
In inter-state systems states seen as
more legitimate when nations are
presented by states. Create inspiration
- music, literature.
Negative: promotes ideas of chauvinism
(belief that nation is superior),
xenophobia (hate of foreigners),
militarism (solving my military means).
Threat to peace, promotes break up of
states, makes it more difficult for
states to cooperate.
-<